主管  上海市教育委员会

      主办  上海出版印刷高等专科学校

      ISSN  1007-1938

      CN  31-1643/TS

      生成式人工智能辅助作品著作权侵权判定的理念塑造与规则调适

      The concept shaping and rule adjustment of generative artificial intelligence-assisted determination of copyright infringement of works

      • 摘要: 生成式人工智能在深刻改变知识创新生态的同时,持续引发新型著作权侵权纠纷,使传统著作权侵权判定规则面临挑战:“接触”要件适用失灵、“实质性相似”要件适用受限和“合理使用”抗辩边界模糊。《“十五五”规划建议》为人工智能时代著作权侵权判定的理念革新与规则调适提供了根本遵循。司法裁判应秉持“促进技术产业发展”、“保障创作主体权益”和“推动知识普惠繁荣”的价值理念,妥善协调好多元利益关系。相应地,著作权侵权判定规则需进行谦抑化调适:“接触”判断应趋向严格审慎,回归立法主旨并援引技术辅助;“实质性相似”推定需引入客观标准,同时考察风格挪用和市场替代双重因素;合理使用情形应适度拓展,可在既有规范基础上适时转化吸收域外立法中的轻微使用、转换性使用等例外类型。

         

        Abstract: While generative artificial intelligence is profoundly transforming the knowledge innovation ecosystem, it continuously triggers new types of copyright infringement disputes, posing challenges to traditional copyright infringement determination rules: the application of the "access" element is ineffective, the application of the "substantial similarity" element is restricted, and the boundary of the "fair use" defense is blurred. The "Proposal for the 15th Five-Year Plan" provides fundamental guidance for the conceptual innovation and rule adjustment of copyright infringement determination in the era of artificial intelligence. Judicial decisions should adhere to the value concepts of "promoting the development of the technology industry", "safeguarding the rights and interests of creative subjects", and "promoting the inclusive and prosperous development of knowledge", and properly coordinate multiple interests. Correspondingly, the rules for determining copyright infringement need to be adjusted in a more restrained way: the "access" judgment should tend to be strict and prudent, return to the legislative purpose and invoke technical assistance; The presumption of "substantial similarity" needs to introduce objective standards and simultaneously examine the dual factors of style appropriation and market substitution. The scenarios of fair use should be moderately expanded. On the basis of existing norms, exceptional types such as minor use and transformative use in foreign legislation can be timely transformed and absorbed.

         

      /

      返回文章
      返回