主管  上海市教育委员会

      主办  上海出版印刷高等专科学校

      ISSN  1007-1938

      CN  31-1643/TS

      新闻作品出版中人工智能训练的著作权限制:利益平衡与路径选择

      • 摘要: 新闻作品作为具有独创性的智力成果,已成为人工智能训练的重要语料,使新闻作品出版著作权治理形成了“新闻著作权人-人工智能训练者-公众”的新三元框架。传统著作权限制条款在新技术语境下面临调节失灵,而目前的框架设计尝试又难以在三者之间实现利益平衡。通过比较目前出现的灵活性“合理使用”、“列举式例外+选择退出”以及“选择进入”三种路径,认为三者均没有完全实现人工智能时代新闻出版的利益平衡;建议借鉴“教学需要式”著作权限制行为的分级模式,构建“合理使用+法定许可+授权协议”的复合型制度框架,并辅以集体管理组织、技术标准化与透明度义务等配套措施,以实现新闻出版者经济利益保障、人工智能训练需求满足与公众公共利益维护三者的动态平衡。

         

        Abstract: Against the backdrop of the rapid development of generative artificial intelligence, news works, due to their timeliness and authenticity, have become an important corpus for AI training, thereby reshaping copyright governance into a new tripartite framework of “news copyright holders–AI trainers–the public.” However, the large-scale use of news works by AI may erode the copyright interests of news publishers, while also raising challenges regarding the legitimacy of AI training and the safeguarding of public interests. Traditional copyright limitations have shown regulatory failure in the new technological context, and current framework designs likewise struggle to achieve a balance of interests among the three stakeholders. By comparing the approaches of the United States, the European Union, and scholarly proposals in China, this study finds that none of them has fully realized an equitable balance in the context of AI and news publishing. It is therefore suggested to adopt a tiered model of copyright limitations inspired by the “educational needs” framework, and to construct a composite system combining “fair use + statutory licensing + licensing agreements, ” supplemented by collective management organizations, technical standardization, and transparency obligations. Such a framework aims to dynamically balance the protection of publishers’ economic interests, the fulfillment of AI training needs, and the safeguarding of the public interest.

         

      /

      返回文章
      返回