主管  上海市教育委员会

      主办  上海出版印刷高等专科学校

      ISSN  1007-1938

      CN  31-1643/TS

      基于优秀编辑访谈视角的科技期刊青年编辑成长关键要素与启示

      Key Factors and Insights for the Growth of Young Editors in Scientific and Technical Journals: Perspectives from Interviews with Excellent Editors

      • 摘要: 创新中国科技期刊人才培养研究视角,为青年编辑的成长提供理论指导和经验借鉴。文章以“期刊视界”公众号和《中国科技期刊研究》38份优秀办刊人物访谈内容/报道材料等涉及的青年编辑成长观点为文本资料,采用主题分析法,剖析优秀编辑视角下科技期刊青年编辑成长关键要素。结果发现,青年编辑成长关键要素包括8个主节点:职业心态、职业规划、知识储备、人际交往、创新与服务、编辑技能、学习与成长机制、组织支持,可进一步归纳为自我驱动力、专业知识与能力发展、组织支持与机制保障3大主范畴。其中,自我驱动力(内因)是青年编辑实现快速成长的动力之源;过硬的专业知识与复合能力(根基),是青年编辑立身之本与发展之道;组织支持与机制保障(外因),是青年编辑成长的坚实保障。提出对青年编辑人才培养的启示:加强职业认同,制定发展规划;树立终身学习理念,形成扎实的知识储备;多措并举,培养核心业务能力;培养创新思维,敢于推陈出新;制定科学的培养机制与考核机制。

         

        Abstract:
        Editors are the core executors in the publication and operation of scientific and technical journals. Most existing research on editor talent cultivation has been conducted from the perspective of external environment or publisher training, while discussions on editor training strategies based on interviews with excellent editors are rare. Excellent editors have remarkable achievements in journal management, and their practices, insights, and reflections during their professional growth as editors contain valuable wisdom and referential methods, which can provide theoretical guidance and empirical references for the professional growth of young editors.The article utilizes the "Journal Vision" WeChat official account and interview content/report materials from 38 outstanding journal editors of Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals as textual materials, employing thematic analysis and assisted by the large language model Kimi K2 flagship model to accurately extract and summarize the core viewpoints from the interview content, in order to analyze the key elements of the growth of young editors in scientific and technical journals from the perspective of outstanding editors.The research findings reveal that the growth factors of young editors consist of 25 sub-nodes, which can be summarized into 8 main nodes: professional mindset, career planning, knowledge reserve, interpersonal communication, innovation and service, editing skills, learning and growth mechanism, and organizational support. Combining the thematic associations between the main nodes, it is further summarized into three major categories: self-motivation, professional knowledge and ability development, and organizational support and mechanism guarantee. Through selective coding, a "storyline" is sorted out, and a key element model for the growth of young editors in scientific and technical journals is constructed: "self-motivation (internal factors)", "professional knowledge and ability development (foundation)", and "organizational support and mechanism guarantee (external factors)" constitute a "trinity" model for the talent cultivation of young editors in scientific and technical journals. The three elements complement each other and jointly determine the speed, breadth, and height of the growth of young editors. From the thematic analysis of interview content, it can be seen that in the professional growth process of young editors, good self-motivation is required; young editors of scientific and technical journals should become knowledgeable and competent talents: they must systematically master subject-specific knowledge, editing and publishing theories, process norms, and industry standards, as well as keep up with industry development trends, actively learn new skills and knowledge, adapt to the constantly changing domestic and international publishing environment, and possess innovative thinking to bring forth the old and create the new in journal management measures, thereby enhancing the core competitiveness of the journal, as well as possessing high communication and interpersonal skills; organizational support and mechanism guarantee are the solid guarantees for the growth of young editors.Based on the results of the thematic analysis, insights for the cultivation of young editorial talent are proposed: strengthen professional identity and formulate development plans; establish a lifelong learning concept and build a solid knowledge base; adopt multiple measures to cultivate core business skills; foster innovative thinking and dare to innovate; and establish scientific training and assessment mechanisms.

         

      /

      返回文章
      返回